Human bycatch Sian Powell From: The Australian
KYAW-KYAW grimaces as he explains how he was sold, like a spare bit of machinery, to a Thai trawler captain. And how his life then slid into a nightmare of beatings, amphetamines, perpetually interrupted sleep and casual death.
Kyaw-Kyaw is 25 years old, and he can’t read or write. When he was 15 he fled from the violence and crushing poverty of eastern Burma’s Karen state and wound up in the Thai border town of Mae Sot, where he earned a bare living tending water buffalo.
A year ago, a broker arrived in his village offering work and a tempting, up-front inducement. “The broker told me I would have a good job and he gave me 8000 baht [$270] cash,” Kyaw-Kyaw says. “I asked him the nature of the work but he didn’t answer. He just said I would earn 5000 baht ($170) a month.” The broker took him south to the coast and directly to the Thai trawler – which is where he first learned he would be working at sea. “He sold me straight to the fishing boat,” Kyaw-Kyaw says with some bitterness.
Start of sidebar. Skip to end of sidebar.
Related CoverageThailand arrests 130 Tamils
Adelaide Now, 12 Oct 2010
Refugee boat ‘rescue’ suspect
Herald Sun, 12 Oct 2010
The Australian, 16 Sep 2010
ASIO leaves arrivals in detention limbo
Australia spends many millions of dollars a year on wild-caught fish from Thailand, where the industry is fed by thousands of boats of varying sizes and degrees of shabbiness. They are crewed largely by migrant Burmese, with some Cambodians and a smaller proportion of Laotians and Thais; most of them endure appalling conditions at sea for little pay. Imprisoned by the vast blue of the world’s oceans, they are routinely “sold” by brokers, or by one captain to another. They tell of spending months at sea without seeing land, taking amphetamines to keep working, stitching up their own wounds, trying to understand instructions in another language, enduring assaults and the threat of death. They have been described as the slaves of the modern age.
Thailand’s deep-sea fishing vessels range for thousands of kilometres, from eastern Indonesian waters all the way to Somalia and Yemen, and many stay at sea for months or even years, the crews regularly transferring the catch to a mothership and receiving supplies of food and water in return. Sometimes these vessels have legal concessions, but often they poach. The captains are nearly always Thai, and they usually carry a pistol to maintain discipline. Stories of casual and never-reported murder are common. Tales abound of put-upon crew trying to escape: leaping overboard if there is any hope at all, or fleeing into strange and pathless jungles in Indonesia and elsewhere.
The UN Food and Agriculture Organisation’s 2009 National Fishery Sector Overview for Thailand estimates that in 2007 the marine catch was worth 63 billion baht, or about $2.15 billion. Some 60 per cent of the haul, which included threadfin bream, Indo-Pacific mackerel, coastal tuna, big-eye snapper, squid, sardines, round scad and anchovies, was from Thai waters; the rest was caught by the Thai fleet elsewhere. The report concludes that the fishing sector faces various obstacles including “persistent difficulties in recruiting the crews” and problems arising from poaching. “Thai fishing vessels are frequently seized by neighbouring coastal states, and skippers accused of illegal fishing and/or unlawful intrusion in the EEZ [exclusive economic zone] of the country concerned,” it notes drily.
It’s a big industry, and one that has links with nations around the world. According to the Australian Bureau of Agricultural and Resource Economics’ Australian Fisheries Statistics 2009 report, Thailand sold Australia at least $24 million worth of frozen fish, fish ¬fillets, smoked, dried and salted fish, fish meal, fish balls, fish cake, fish sausages, caviar and caviar substitutes, and fish livers and roes. This figure excludes canned fish and seafood, which are mostly produced from imported materials. And besides exports, domestic consumption in Thailand is huge.
It seems Thai trawlers have not yet encroached into Australian waters, but Tamsin Allen, acting spokeswoman for the Australian Fisheries Management Authority, says they have been seen nearby. “Australian surveillance aircraft regularly sight large mothership and carrier-type boats operating near the Australian-Indonesian EEZ boundary; these vessels have been identified as operating in support of smaller fishing vessels in Indonesian waters. The large motherships sighted north of Australia are often of Thai origin.”
Kyaw-Kyaw, with the muscles of hard work bulging under his T-shirt, saw one of the men on his trawler fall overboard. It seems the man was not a valued crew member, because he was left to drown. “Nobody helped him,” Kyaw-Kyaw says, impassively. “We weren’t so far from shore, maybe about two kilometres. He might be dead or alive; nobody knows what happened to him.”
After eight months of working on the boat, on voyages rarely longer than a fortnight, and after fruitless requests for his wages, Kyaw-Kyaw decided to make a run for it. He asked again for money, this time saying he wanted to go to a karaoke bar, which in Thailand is often a place of drinking and commercial sex. The crew leader, from the Mon people of Thailand and Burma, grumbled, but finally gave him 3000 baht ($100). Kyaw-Kyaw took it and ran. For eight months’ work, often waking up every few hours at night to bring the catch in, he had a grand total of 11,000 baht (about $380) to show for it – and 8000 of that was the inducement to travel with the broker.
Kyaw-Kyaw says he was beaten twice, for minor infractions. Drug use was rife on the boat and a tablet of amphetamine cost just 250 baht ($8.50). He shrugs. Now he has found work as a gardener in Bangkok, and his life is much easier. As well as being unable to read or write, he can’t speak Thai very well, so his options are limited. For the moment, though, he is simply happy to be off the boat.
Like the mafia
Aung Thu Ya, president of the Seafarrers’ Union of Burma, says the Thai fishing industry is enmeshed in criminality. Falsified documents, corruption, systematic poaching, assault, forced labour: the billion-dollar trade fuels multi-dimensional and multi-faceted evil. “The nature of the industry is like the mafia,” he says in his office in Bangkok, explaining that the trawlers both steal fish from other countries and steal wages and liberty from the crews. Aung Thu Ya says that, according to eyewitnesses and other reports, between 300 and 1000 men have been murdered on the Thai fleet since 1995.
More die as a result of neglect. Aung Thu Ya proffers legal papers connected with the Prapasnavee case. In mid-2006, the Prapasnavee fleet of six trawlers returned to Mahachai port near Bangkok from a three-year voyage in Indonesian waters. The owners, the Pongsataporn family, had spent months trying and failing to negotiate an extended fishing concession for the boats. The fleet spent the time hiding in Indonesian waters, banned from entering ports, and unable to restock on food and supplies. Finally the captains were ordered to return to Thailand.
Two men had died before the boats left Indonesian waters; during the return voyage an average of three men died each day from malnutrition. The boat captains ordered the bodies to be dumped overboard. By the time the fleet reached Thailand 39 men had died, and one died later in hospital.
With the help of various aid agencies, the surviving workers sued the owners and got the police involved. The captains fled; the owners denied they were aware of conditions on the boats, and said they did not have the captains’ full names and addresses. No one has been ¬convicted, and Aung Thu Ya understands only minimal back-pay (10,000 to 40,000 baht; $340 to $1360 for years of work) has been given to those workers who agreed to the owners’ offers. “According to the stories of our fishermen, the skippers and officers – they beat, they hit, they kill,” says Aung Thu Ya. “So many cases. They torture the fishermen. But the ¬industry is booming.”
Inland from Mahachai port, in the warren of streets in the town, a few seafarers talk about their lives. Aye is very handsome, with smooth brown skin and bright teeth, and he smiles a lot. He knows, all too well, how much endurance is needed to work on Thai fishing trawlers, but he worries about having his photo taken and his name used. He fears reprisals if he tells his story. It gets worse: the people in charge of the office where he agrees to meet don’t even want their organisation named; they, too, mutter about the “mafia” culture of the fishing industry.
Sitting casually on the tiled floor, Aye talks about the horrors of life at sea. He talks about men who suffer without medicine when they’re ill, who are beaten because they fail to understand instructions in Thai, and of how he once spent two years at sea without seeing land. Aye, now 29, is from Rangoon, and he has been working on the boats for 15 years. Why does he carry on? He says he doesn’t know how to do anything else, and doesn’t know how to start.
Workers like him, with experience and some knowledge of the Thai language, have an easier time at sea. That evening he planned to catch the bus to Nakhon Si Thammarat, on Thailand’s east coast, opposite Phuket, to board a fishing boat, and earn perhaps 5000 baht ($170) a month, with no need to pay for food or accommodation. “I will go anywhere, if I can earn more money, I will go. I have been married and divorced. My aim and my goal is to earn a lot of money. I want to live like other people.”
After all, he has seen the worst of it now. In 2005, he says he saw a Burmese worker argue first with the boat’s Thai engineer, and then with the Thai captain. The captain took out a gun and shot the worker, whose body slumped into the sea. Nothing more happened, either to the ¬captain or the witnesses. “I was living at sea for a long time; how could I report it?” Aye asks. “How can we, because we are in the hands of the ¬captain.” He says with no hard evidence it would be meaningless to report such a thing to the Thai police, and laughs at the thought he could have reported it to the Burmese embassy. “We don’t even know where the embassy is.”
Until recently, Anna Engblom worked as a project officer with the International Labour Organisation in Bangkok, which has commissioned research into the exploitation in Thailand’s fishing industry. In 2006, according to figures quoted by the UN, there were 12,552 ¬registered fishing vessels in Thailand, employing tens of thousands of workers. “It’s one of the worst sectors for migrant labourers,” Engblom says. “There are very few Thais working as crew. This work is considered so hard and challenging and tough, Thais really don’t want to do it.”
Engblom says she has been told by one worker that he spent three years without once setting foot on dry land: the trawler was regularly resupplied at sea, its catch transferred to a nearby mothership. Another told her that he saw a troublemaker thrown overboard; his body was later brought up in a net, disentangled and thrown overboard again. “When they see another boat, they just jump,” Engblom says. “They just hope they will be picked up.”
Lured, deceived, threatened: many of these workers are given little choice about signing up, and if they are migrants, legal or otherwise, they are afraid to complain to the Thai authorities. Many of them, Engblom notes, willingly go to sea. But sometimes they think it will only be a short voyage and then they find themselves at sea for two years. Others are told the work will be a job in port. Some wake up after a big night carousing and find themselves on board and out of sight of land. Others wake after a big night to be told they owe a karaoke bar thousands of baht and must pay their debt. The Thai navy occasionally stops boats, Engblom says, but there are few prosecutions.
Another Burmese worker, who again wants to keep his head down and his name secret, says he has spent 21 years on the boats, frequently on poaching voyages. Originally from Rangoon, Min says he was on one voyage in Indonesian waters that lasted three years. Another time, he and his shipmates had to abandon ship when their boat was caught poaching in Burmese waters. They floated in the sea for three days before they were rescued by another trawler. “We had an emergency light, but the boat was confiscated by the Burmese authorities,” he says.
Min, who freely admits he used heroin on board the boats, says trawler work can be almost unendurable for newcomers who have no skills, who have been sold by brokers with no explanation of what is expected of them. Thin and very dark-skinned, he seems weary, and he says his eyes no longer function very well. He may have cataracts; or he may have a more serious illness – but at least on land he can seek treatment. At sea, his health and wellbeing were a low priority. “If there’s an accident, or if you’re sick, you die,” he says. “Like that.” He says the brokers have no compunction; they transport workers like so much cargo, lock them up in safe houses, promise them different jobs and send them to sea.
The plight of these wretched and often unwitting seafarers has stirred sympathies internationally. Mark Zirnsak, director of the Uniting Church in Victoria and Tasmania’s Justice and International Mission, visited Bangkok recently to find out more about life on the boats of the Thai fishing fleet and in the seafood processing factories. “We are looking at what we can put to the seafood importers in Australia about what they could do,” he says. “As long as companies accept Thai seafood and fish produced under these appalling conditions, it’s hard to see why Thais would be interested in addressing these conditions.” He notes that there’s never been a prosecution of an Australian person or company for involvement in slavery such as is prevalent in the Thai fishing industry, adding: “They fit the definition of slaves, there’s no doubt about that.”
Zirnsak has been in touch with Norm Grant, executive chairman of the Seafood Importers Association of Australasia, who is sympathetic, although concerned that it would be almost impossible to determine the vessel provenance of fish bought from Thailand, and worried that any boycott could come down like a mallet on the innocent. “I’m sure every importer would be happy to boycott fish from boats abusing their crews, but clearly there would be problems in knowing which ones they are,” Grant says.
“Boycotting all wild-caught seafood would be economically catastrophic to those doing the right thing. However, I think with careful planning it would be possible to narrow down the likely boats and identify the most likely fish products and factories for further scrutiny.” He has asked the association’s members to request evidence of labour law compliance when they order, and has agreed to write again to ask them to ensure their suppliers are not buying from sources that might countenance labour abuse.
Abuse, or slavery? Eaklak Loomchomkhae, chief of the Mirror Foundation’s Anti Human Trafficking Operation Centre, based in Bangkok, believes many of those who work on the fishing fleet are at the enslaved end of the labour arc. The centre has done a lot of work on the matter, interviewing victims and officials, assisting Thai workers and their families, and compiling a soon-to-be-published research paper.
“Slaves, they are slaves,” Eaklak says, with no doubt in his voice. He says he is not sure of the proportion of fishing crew who are at sea against their will, but he insists it’s a very big and ¬growing problem, fuelled by a chronic labour shortage on the boats. Tackling the mess is hugely difficult, he adds. Many of the boat-owners are linked to politicians, and they have a lot of power. Some in the government do want to clean up the industry but, he sighs, “it’s a big area, and it’s big money – it’s very difficult”.
Aye agrees and – from his relaxed position on the office floor in Mahachai – he waxes philosophical. He thinks the idea of cleaning up the industry is great on paper, but doomed in practice, and he says the men who work on Thai boats have almost no access to justice. He remembers how he was arrested in the port town of Ranong 10 years ago because he had no papers and he wasn’t in Thailand legally. He says Thai authorities transported him to an island – he doesn’t know its name – and a Burmese broker arrived to arrange his transfer onto a trawler.
“The broker said, ‘If you work on the fishing boat, you will earn 5000 baht’,” Aye says, laughing at the suggestion he could have refused and run away. “I would get lost on that island, I would be starving on that island. I had no choice. We had to agree, and after that we had to work out a way of escape. When you try to escape, you have to make sure it’s safe. But if you make the decision, and they catch you, they will kill you.”
He waited until night, when the trawler was kilometres offshore in the Gulf of Thailand, and jumped overboard wearing only his underpants and clutching a flat piece of polystyrene. He had no money, no passport, no papers. “I could see the lights, but I was so far away. If I jumped during the day I would have been shot. It took hours to get to shore, maybe four to eight. I couldn’t swim that far. I could just float with the currents.”
When he reached land, he wandered around until he found some Burmese people, who fed him and lent him some clothes. He wound up staying in Chumphon district, a long way south of Bangkok, where he lived for the next three to four years, working casually on boats.
Aye believes some official recognition of the industry crisis would help. “It would be good if the Thai government set up new laws,” he says. “We lose 90 per cent of our rights.” Anyway, like many of the workers, he is unsure of what he could do at sea, especially if the trawlers are fishing illegally – which is usually the case. “Thailand is a big thief,” he says. “If the boats are caught on radar, they run.” And they don’t care what misery they leave in their wake.